PlayMusic and looping music

4 replies to this topic
Posted 1+ years ago #1

I noticed that in HTML 5 + Firefox, PlayMusic("music.ogg",1) does not loop the music.

(It does loop in HTML 5 + Chrome.)

Therefore, for the time being, I have added this MusicState check to OnUpdate to achieve a "manual" kind of looping:

Method OnUpdate:Int()
  ' music is not playing
  If (MusicState() = 0) Then
    ' start music
  End If

End Method

There is a slight pause between two plays.

By the way, I switched to using OGG for music in HTML 5 (MP3 in Flash) since my song, which lasts only about 5 seconds, would be sized 600 KB in WAV, while the OGG version is only 70 KB.

Of course the downside of OGG is that it does not work under IE. So people who play my game as HTML 5 + IE would hear no music at all.

In that respect I suppose HTML 5 is still to be seen as "hey that's nice that it works as HTML 5 too" but not as the main target to make a game for.

Posted 1+ years ago #2

Of course the downside of OGG is that it does not work under IE. So people who play my game as HTML 5 + IE would hear no music at all.

Can't you check the browser ID string and if it's IE then load/use the WAV file else use/load the OGG?

EDIT: See here.

Posted 1+ years ago #3

That is very useful, thanks. I could then use the MP3 version for IE.

Posted 1+ years ago #4

With the user-agent check added I am now using this TSoundSystem class for playing music from my HTML5 / Flash game:

' soundsystem.monkey

Import mojo


Function getUserAgent:String() = "function (){return navigator.userAgent;}"

Class TSoundSystem
	Global gMusicExtension:String
	Global gMusicEnabled:Bool = True
	Function init:Void()
		' default value
		gMusicExtension = "mp3"
		' target is flash	
		#if TARGET="flash"
			gMusicExtension = "mp3"
		' target is html5			
		#if TARGET="html5"
			Local userAgent:String = getUserAgent()
			' browser is probably IE
			If (userAgent.Find("MSIE") <> -1) Then
				gMusicExtension = "mp3"
			' browser is probably non-IE
				gMusicExtension = "ogg"
			End If
	End Function

	Function playMusic:Void(pBaseFileName:String)
		If (gMusicEnabled) Then
		End If
	End Function

I know the way I check for MSIE in the user-agent string is not perfect, as for example Opera might also have MSIE in the user-agent. (As explained in the link posted by therevills here). My main concern is however to have music playing in FF, IE, and Chrome.

Now I can use


at the start of my game, it will decide what extension is to be used. Afterwards I can use


and it will play the correct one, assuming that both mymusic.ogg and mymusic.mp3 are available in my /music folder.

Posted 1+ years ago #5

I have had trouble with sound too. I have considered directing IE users to Chrome Frame. Haven't tried it myself, but according to the documentation, you don't need administrative rights to install it. Though I suppose you don't need administrative rights to install the Chrome Browser either. I guess with the frame, you're still "running" IE but you're actually using Google's V8 Engine. Perhaps there is a way trigger the installation automatically?